If you are weighing one long tray vs two short trays for a standing desk, you are really comparing the Bostitch Office Konnect Wide Accessory Tray and the Matace 1 Pack Rubber Extra Large Shoe Tray. One is a compact, stackable desktop organizer with a built-in divider for cords and small essentials, while the other is a single 16×55 in rubber run built for wide, floor level coverage. Your decision shapes how slack behaves when you raise the frame, how the floor looks, and how quick cleanup feels. For wider planning, explore our Cable Management and Under-Desk hub to see how trays fit with sleeves and channels.
Assessed for November 2026, this comparison researched both layouts for lift friendly use, footprint, containment, and upkeep. You will learn where a modular wide tray keeps desktop clutter under control and where an extra large low profile mat calms a full width power zone. If you want smooth height changes without snags or drift, use this guide to match your desk width and daily habits to the right layout.
This article contains affiliate links. If you buy through one of our links, CustomPCGaming may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Commissions never influence which products we recommend or how we rank them. Read our Affiliate Disclosure for details.
Quick Picks at a Glance
Prime Matace Extra Large Rubber Boot Tray 16×55 Inch
Prime Bostitch Konnect Wide Accessory Tray White
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated.
Pros
- Generous length holds a full family lineup of shoes and boots
- Sturdy recyclable rubber build feels more durable and non slip than plastic
- Raised edge effectively contains water, dirt and pet messes
- Versatile for indoor and outdoor use across entryway, garage and garden
- Simple rinse to clean with no floor damage
Cons
- Large 55 inch length requires wide entryway space and may overwhelm small foyers
- 7 pound weight and hand wash only care make frequent moving and cleaning less convenient
- Basic black solid design and rubber material may have initial odor and limited style options
The Matace Extra Large Shoe Tray is a 55 by 16 inch rubber boot mat designed for entryways, mudrooms, garages and foyers. It suits busy households that need one slim tray to organize multiple pairs of shoes, tall boots and umbrellas.
The standout 1.18 inch raised edge does a solid job containing rainwater, snow melt, mud and pet food spills. The waterproof, non slip rubber surface keeps footwear in place while protecting wood, tile and carpet floors underneath.
Made from 100 percent recyclable rubber, the tray feels sturdy, abrasion resistant and comfortable underfoot compared to thin plastic alternatives. The classic black rectangular design looks neat indoors or outdoors and rinses clean with just water.
The large footprint needs ample floor space, so measure your entryway before ordering. At 7 pounds it feels substantial, and hand wash only care plus possible initial rubber odor may bother sensitive users.
For anyone wanting durable, low maintenance floor protection with extra length for the whole family, this Matace tray is a practical pick. It keeps clutter contained, floors dry and daily cleanups simple.
Brand: MataceCarpet, Model: new boot tray, Material: 100 percent recyclable rubber in black with oil rubbed finish.
Dimensions: 55 inch L x 16 inch W x 1.18 inch H, Weight: 7 pounds, Shape: Rectangular, Style: Classic Solid.
Recommended uses: Mud room, garage, foyer, garden, indoor and outdoor for shoes, boots, plants, pet food, umbrellas and trunk storage.
Care and safety: Hand wash only, rinse with water, waterproof, non slip, non toxic and safe, will not corrode floors.
Pros
- Highly rated organization for small desktop essentials like sticky notes and paperclips
- Smart two-in-one divided layout improves sorting without adding footprint
- Fully stackable and compatible with other Konnect pieces for custom setups
- Lightweight, durable plastic with modern white finish that suits any workspace
- Simple open design with easy access and quick cleanup
Cons
- Lightweight plastic construction is not ideal for heavy tools or bulky items
- White polished surface can show dust and fingerprints and needs regular wiping
- Most useful as part of the Konnect system rather than as a large standalone organizer
The Bostitch Office Konnect Wide Accessory Tray is a modular desk organizer designed for students, teachers and home office users. It is made to hold sticky notes, paperclips, cords and other small stationery essentials in one accessible spot.
The standout feature is the built-in short divider that splits the tray into two compartments for better sorting. In daily use, the open top design makes it fast to grab what you need while keeping clutter contained.
Made from polished plastic in a clean white finish, the tray looks modern on any desk. The rectangular shape is wide enough for larger sticky note pads, yet compact enough for tabletop mounting and stacking.
As a lightweight plastic tray, it is not intended for heavy tools or bulky supplies. It also works best as part of the Konnect system, so users looking for a large standalone organizer may want to stack multiple units.
Overall, this is a simple, practical add-on for anyone building a customized Konnect workspace. If you want affordable, stackable storage that saves desk space and keeps small items tidy, this tray is an easy choice.
Brand Bostitch, Model KT2-WDCUP-WHT, Color White, Material Plastic with polished finish. Rectangular tabletop tray designed for stationery and supply organization.
Features two compartments with a built-in short divider and open top access. Special features include stackable design for vertical desk storage.
Compatible with the Konnect Desk Organizer Power Base, Stackable Storage Tray and Stackable Pencil Cup. Backed by a limited 3-year manufacturer warranty.
Use this wide tray as a single catch-all for sticky notes and clips, or stack two or more to build vertical storage. Place frequently used items on top for fastest access.
Pair it with the Konnect Power Base for a powered hub, then add the Storage Tray or Pencil Cup around it. The modular fit keeps every piece aligned and stable.
For classrooms or shared desks, assign each compartment to a supply type to reduce clutter. Wipe the plastic clean regularly to keep the white finish looking fresh.
How They Compare
Coverage Length and Cable Span
The Matace 1 Pack Rubber Extra Large Shoe Tray is defined by its 16×55 in rectangular footprint, per the spec sheet, which makes it a true single span option. You can center it under a wide standing frame, run it along a wall, or place a surge protector plus bricks in one visible line. The Bostitch Office Konnect Wide Accessory Tray takes the opposite path, as a wide accessory tray that organizes sticky notes, paperclips, cords, and other small desktop essentials in a compact zone.
When you weigh one long tray vs two short trays for a standing desk, the Matace 1 Pack Rubber Extra Large Shoe Tray keeps adapters together in one 55 in run to check before you lift. The Bostitch Office Konnect Wide Accessory Tray splits control into compact left and right zones for display leads and charging leads. If you dislike mid span sag, the long run feels calmer, while divided trays suit narrower tops. See 8 RGB LED strips for a corner desk glow for glow ideas that stay clear of power.
Placement and Compatibility With Standing Desks
Placement is where the designs diverge. The Bostitch Office Konnect Wide Accessory Tray is compatible with the Konnect Desk Organizer Power Base and other Konnect Stackables, per the spec sheet, and you can stack multiple trays to optimize storage and save coveted desk space. That system lives on the desktop, so notes, clips, and short cords lift with the surface and stay within reach. The Matace 1 Pack Rubber Extra Large Shoe Tray is a lay flat rubber tray with non-slip character and abrasion resistance, so it stays grounded while your desk rises above it.
Consider how you like to manage height shifts. The Bostitch Office Konnect Wide Accessory Tray keeps small gear traveling with you, which suits users who keep a hub or dock on top. The Matace 1 Pack Rubber Extra Large Shoe Tray keeps heavy bricks low, which owners commonly report as steady during tall lifts. Neither option lists a screw mount channel in the provided specs, so rely on friction, weight, and tidy routing rather than bolts. To keep the top minimal while the frame moves, review this minimalist RGB desk setup for layout ideas that reduce surface load.
Containment, Dividers and Edge Control
The Bostitch Office Konnect Wide Accessory Tray uses a built-in, short divider for two-in-one organization, so you can keep cords apart from sticky notes and paperclips without adding an extra unit. That small split helps on standing desks because light items shift when you adjust height or bump the frame. The Matace 1 Pack Rubber Extra Large Shoe Tray uses a raised edge increased to 1.18in after collecting suggestions from 150 volunteers, per the spec sheet. That lip helps keep rolling adapters, dust, and small spills from spreading across your floor.
Match containment to your mess. Pick the Bostitch Office Konnect Wide Accessory Tray if your problem is surface tangles, mixed clips, and short charger leads that wander on top. Pick the Matace 1 Pack Rubber Extra Large Shoe Tray if your problem is floor sprawl, a drifting power strip, or debris collecting around feet and wheels. Owners commonly report that a low lip limits drift while still allowing airflow around bricks, though you should leave space and avoid stacking adapters.
Material, Cleaning, Ratings and Long Term Ownership
Materials show how each choice ages in daily use. The Matace 1 Pack Rubber Extra Large Shoe Tray uses 100% recyclable rubber with abrasion resistance and non-slip use, per the spec sheet, and it holds a 3.9 out of 5 rating from 4224 reviews. You can rinse it with water, and it will not corrode your floor, which helps on hardwood or laminate. The Bostitch Office Konnect Wide Accessory Tray is a white organizer with a three-year limited warranty, per the spec sheet, and it holds a 4.6 out of 5 rating from 400 reviews.
For ownership, the Matace 1 Pack Rubber Extra Large Shoe Tray resists deformation and rinses clean, while the Bostitch Office Konnect Wide Accessory Tray stacks vertically to save desk space. The trade-off is clear, the Bostitch Office Konnect Wide Accessory Tray suits small essentials but is not a good fit for a full size surge protector, while the Matace 1 Pack Rubber Extra Large Shoe Tray needs room for its 55 in footprint. For upgrades that avoid tray load, compare BenQ ScreenBar Halo 2 vs Quntis options that mount at the display.
Which One Should You Get
Choose Bostitch Office Konnect Wide Accessory Tray if you work at a compact or mid size standing desk and your clutter lives on the surface. You keep sticky notes, paperclips, short USB leads, and earbuds in a divided zone that rises with you, and you like stacking an extra tray later rather than dedicating floor space to a 55 in mat. This route suits students, renters, and hybrid workers who want quick desktop order and a three-year limited warranty backing.
Choose Matace 1 Pack Rubber Extra Large Shoe Tray if you want one long tray vs two short trays for a standing desk settled in favor of full width floor control. You have a wide frame, a floor level strip, and multiple bricks that shed slack downward, and you prefer the more premium choice with 100% recyclable rubber and a 1.18in raised edge that rinses clean with water. This route suits gamers and home office users with room for a 16×55 in run who want one zone to check before each lift.
Who Should Skip Both
If you run a multi monitor battlestation that needs an enclosed steel channel, a locking spine, or a wall routed power hub, this pair is not ideal for your build. Neither the Bostitch Office Konnect Wide Accessory Tray nor the Matace 1 Pack Rubber Extra Large Shoe Tray provides a bolted under desk enclosure or a heat rated power housing, and neither hides thick display and power bundles completely. You should look at a dedicated metal tray with proper mounts, check clearance against your frame, and follow the manufacturer mounting instructions.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is one long tray better than two short trays for a standing desk that moves every day?
For daily height changes, the Matace 1 Pack Rubber Extra Large Shoe Tray keeps floor level slack in a single 16×55 in line so you can confirm clearance before you lift. The Bostitch Office Konnect Wide Accessory Tray gives you better desktop separation for small cords and supplies that travel with the top. Pick length if your mess spreads wide, pick split trays if your mess clusters near your hands.
Can the Matace 1 Pack Rubber Extra Large Shoe Tray protect wood floors under a standing desk?
Yes, per the spec sheet it uses 100% recyclable rubber that will not corrode your floor and a 1.18in raised edge to limit spread. You can rinse it with water, which helps where dust collects around feet. Leave airflow around bricks and confirm your desk feet and chair mat still sit level.
Does the Bostitch Office Konnect Wide Accessory Tray need the Konnect Power Base to work?
No, you can use the Bostitch Office Konnect Wide Accessory Tray alone to organize sticky notes, paperclips, cords, and other small essentials with its built-in short divider. Compatibility with the Konnect Desk Organizer Power Base and other Konnect Stackables lets you stack multiple trays to save desk space later. It carries a three-year limited warranty, per the spec sheet, whether you expand or not.
Write Your Review
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your experience!