When you compare a mesh cable tray vs a solid cable tray for your gaming desk, you are really choosing between open airflow and easy visibility on one side and a cleaner, more hidden look on the other. In this head to head, the open mesh style represents the first approach, while the VIVO Black 17 in Under Desk Cable Management Tray represents the second approach with its partially closed metal design. Your choice affects how your power strip, AV cables, and ethernet wires look from the front of your desk and how quickly you can change them when you upgrade.
If your setup includes a gaming PC, multiple monitors, a headset charger, and a console, cable clutter under your desk can grow quickly and distract from play. You want a tray that matches your desk material, your power strip size, and how often you swap gear when you refresh your build with new accessories. For broader routing ideas to pair with this comparison, browse our Cable Management and Under-Desk guides as you plan your layout as of September 2026.
This article contains affiliate links. If you buy through one of our links, CustomPCGaming may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Commissions never influence which products we recommend or how we rank them. Read our Affiliate Disclosure for details.
Quick Picks at a Glance
Prime VIVO Under Desk Cable Management Tray 16.5 Inch
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated.
Pros
- Sturdy all-metal build supports up to 11 lbs without sagging
- Simple screw-in installation works with most wood desks
- Partially closed design hides clutter while keeping cables accessible
- Slim, minimalist black profile suits home and office decor
Cons
- Requires drilling into desk, not ideal for glass, metal or thin tops
- Single 16.5 inch tray may be tight for very large setups with multiple power strips
- No built-in cable clips or cover, so very thin cables may need extra ties
The VIVO DESK-AC06-1C is a 16.5-inch under-desk cable management tray designed to tame messy power strips and cords. It is built for remote workers, gamers and office users who want a cleaner, more productive setup without cables on the floor.
In daily use, it easily holds a full-size power strip plus chargers, ethernet and AV cables in one hidden spot. The open front makes it simple to plug in new devices or pull out a cable, so you do not have to remove the whole tray for small changes.
The tray features a low-profile steel body with a matte black finish that disappears under most desks. Its partially closed shape keeps bricks and wires concealed from view while still allowing airflow, and the metal frame feels solid and resistant to bending.
Installation requires screwing into a wood or particle board top, so it is not suited for glass or metal desks. The single tray size is perfect for standard setups, but users with extensive gear may need two units for full coverage.
Overall, this VIVO tray delivers a simple, durable and effective fix for under-desk clutter. If you want strong metal construction, easy access and a minimalist look, it is an excellent upgrade for any home or office workstation.
Model DESK-AC06-1C in Black with durable metal construction for indoor use. Measures 16.5 inches long by 3 inches wide with mounting holes spaced 11 inches apart.
Supports up to 11 lbs of power strips, adapters and cables with screw-in installation under wood or particle board desks. Includes mounting screws and 1 year warranty for peace of mind.
How They Compare
Concealment and Desk Appearance
A generic mesh cable tray uses an open grid that keeps every plug and brick visible from below and from the side, which can look busy in a living room or streaming background with RGB lighting. By contrast, the VIVO Black 17 in Under Desk Cable Management Tray uses a partially closed metal body that hides the bulk of your AV cables and ethernet wires while the black finish blends with dark desks. If you care about a tidy front view for video calls or desk photos, you will likely prefer the solid style for how it masks clutter from normal seating height.
A mesh cable tray lets your LED glow pass through the grid and makes it simple to spot which cable goes where without lifting the tray or unplugging anything. The VIVO Black 17 in Under Desk Cable Management Tray keeps things neater from the front, but you will need to reach into its front opening to confirm routing, which takes a moment longer during changes. For a clean visual target, many gamers pair a solid tray with ideas from our minimalist RGB desk setup breakdown to balance glow and concealment in a small room.
Access for Adding and Removing Cables
When you add a new headset dock or swap a DisplayPort cable behind your monitors, a mesh cable tray lets you poke cables through any opening along its length without much planning or rerouting. The VIVO Black 17 in Under Desk Cable Management Tray instead routes you through its front opening, which keeps cords well hidden but asks you to plan entry and exit points before you push plugs through. If you change gear often, you might find the open grid quicker, while you might find the solid tray calmer if your setup stays stable for a long stretch.
Owners commonly report that a mesh cable tray snags less when you pull a thick power brick cord, since you can lift it straight out from above without threading it through a slot. Owners of the VIVO Black 17 in Under Desk Cable Management Tray commonly report that its front opening still makes adding or removing cables simple once you learn the angle, though very stiff cables need a bit of patience and gentle routing. You should think about your own habits and pick easy drop in access over maximum concealment, or the reverse, based on how often you rewire your battlestation.
Mounting Requirements and Load Support
Mounting is where specs matter for safety and stability under a gaming load. The VIVO Black 17 in Under Desk Cable Management Tray installs underneath any wood or particle board desk with the provided screws, with mounting holes set 11” apart, and its durable metal design provides strong support for up to 11 lbs of cables and devices. A typical mesh cable tray also screws under wood tops, but owners commonly report more flex under heavy bricks, so you should check your desk thickness and follow the manufacturer mounting instructions closely before you load it.
If your desk uses glass, a metal frame only, or a thin standing desk top with moving parts, neither screw in style might suit you without extra care and reinforcement. A mesh cable tray often needs multiple screws along its length to stay level, which can be awkward on narrow rails or crossbars that leave little flat area. The VIVO Black 17 in Under Desk Cable Management Tray needs solid wood to bite into at that 11” spacing, so you should confirm under desk clearance for your power strip height and avoid forcing screws into material that could split or crack.
Size Fit for Power Strips and Gaming Gear
Size fit decides whether your surge protector actually sits inside the tray or hangs over the edge and ruins the clean look. The VIVO Black 17 in Under Desk Cable Management Tray measures 16.5” x 3” and is designed to route and conceal your AV cables and power strips for a clean and organized appearance. A mesh cable tray comes in varied widths that owners commonly report as roomy for bricks, but without a published spec here you should measure your own strip and compare it to your available under desk width before you commit to drilling.
For gaming desks with a PC power cable, monitor bricks, and network gear, the VIVO Black 17 in Under Desk Cable Management Tray with that 16.5” length suits compact to mid size strips while keeping ethernet wires tucked out of sight behind the front lip. A mesh cable tray can feel more forgiving for oversized bricks because the sides do not constrain you, though the result looks less uniform from the front where cables remain exposed. To coordinate lighting with your hidden wiring, see our RGB LED Strips for a Corner Desk Glow and plan your glow so it does not expose every cable run.
Which One Should You Get
Choose mesh cable tray if you rewire often, run multiple bricks that need airflow, and want to see every connection at a glance during upgrades. You will appreciate the open access when you swap consoles, docks, or USB hubs for streaming, and you can pair it with sleeves to tame the visible clutter a bit without losing speed. This path suits workshop desks, streaming rigs with rotating gear, and anyone who values speed of changes over a fully hidden front view from the chair.
Choose VIVO Black 17 in Under Desk Cable Management Tray if you want a minimalist front view that hides your power strip and AV cables under a wood or particle board desk. You get a low profile 16.5” footprint, front access for updates, and support for up to 11 lbs, a combination that owners have rated 4.6/5 across 1193 reviews according to the listing. Pair it with careful routing ideas from our how to choose LED desk lighting for eye comfort guide to keep glow tidy as of September 2026.
Who Should Skip Both
Both screw in trays are not ideal for renters who cannot drill, owners of glass top desks, or ultra thin folding tables that lack solid material for screws. If you cannot secure into wood or particle board, or your standing desk frame leaves no flat clearance for a 16.5” tray, you should skip both and look at clamp on or adhesive channels that do not need screws. You should also avoid either option if your power setup lives on the floor far from the desk and would hang with strain on the plugs during height changes.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a mesh cable tray better than a solid cable tray for a gaming PC desk?
Neither style wins for every gamer, it depends on your priority for looks against ease of changes. You might prefer a mesh cable tray if you swap gear weekly and want instant visibility, while you might prefer the VIVO Black 17 in Under Desk Cable Management Tray if you want a hidden front view. We researched owner feedback and spec details, and both approaches can keep AV cables and ethernet wires off the floor when mounted correctly.
Will the VIVO Black 17 in Under Desk Cable Management Tray fit my power strip?
The VIVO Black 17 in Under Desk Cable Management Tray measures 16.5” x 3” with mounting holes 11” apart and supports up to 11 lbs, so you should measure your strip length, height, and plug clearance before you drill. You can place most compact strips and their adapters inside, with ethernet wires and AV cables routed through the front opening for quick tweaks. If your strip is oversized or your desk rail is narrow, a mesh cable tray with an open side might feel more forgiving, but you will trade away some concealment.
Can I use a mesh cable tray or a solid cable tray on a standing desk?
You can use a mesh cable tray or the VIVO Black 17 in Under Desk Cable Management Tray on many fixed height wood desks and on some standing desks that offer a flat wood section with room to move. You should check clearance under the top through the full lift range, confirm the top is wood or particle board that accepts screws, and follow the manufacturer mounting instructions to avoid damage to the top. Both options are not recommended for glass tops or very thin tops, where clamp on solutions often make more sense for renters and mobile setups.
Write Your Review
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your experience!